Brand
Price
Top filters (7)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Type
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Build
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Claimed firmness
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sagging score
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Comfort retention score after eight years – female
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Comfort retention score after eight years – male
Unlock this by becoming a member
Test results (4)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Insulation (mattress warmth)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unused mattress comfort score – female
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unused mattress comfort score – male
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sweat repellent score
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sustainability (2)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Environmental impact score
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Warranty (years)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Features (3)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Handles
Unlock this by becoming a member
Unlock this by becoming a member
Trial period (days)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Related products (1)
Unlock this by becoming a member
Availability
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sort by
Filter by
Mattress reviews
We lab test and compare double and queen mattresses from popular retailers and online bed-in-a-box brands to help you find the right fit for you. Our testing looks at the following factors, which are important for a good night’s sleep:
- comfort and support when new
- comfort and support after eight years of simulated use – the higher the score, the closer the mattress will feel to how it did out of the box
- stabilisation – a higher score means less bouncing and greater stability in the middle of the mattress
- total number of springs and layers
- temperature regulation and sweat absorption.
We recommend mattresses with a CHOICE Expert Rating of 75% or more. Other factors, including poor customer service based on member feedback or visible damage to the mattress on arrival, can factor in to the recommended criteria. Mattresses that score between 70% and 75% are still worth considering.
Shopping links on the CHOICE website
CHOICE is an independent, nonprofit organisation dedicated to helping consumers. Clicking a link will take you to a retailer’s website to shop. While we make money if you buy through some retailer links, this doesn’t influence any of our rankings. 100% of the money we make goes straight back into our nonprofit mission. We’re currently testing this service and will consider providing more shopping links in the future. Tell us what you think.
View table
Displaying all 56 products
Choose a field
Sorry, no products meet the criteria for the filters you've applied.
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Comfort Plus
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1299
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Malibu Firm
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2599
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Chiro Estate
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2199
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Chiro Clarity
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2999
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Chiro Reserve
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1699
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Everyday Comfort MK2
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$899
Unlock this by becoming a member
A.H. Beard King Koil Conforma Element
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Positano
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Conforma Essence
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1299
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Conforma Duo Firm
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Chiro Valor Firm
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Chiro Entice
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Koil Alair
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4000
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard King Coil Chiro Response
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
A.H. Beard Domino Goldberg
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Active Sleep Control
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Art & Science Gold Plus
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Art & Science Platinum
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Art & Science Windsor (previously Silver)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Art & Science Night & Day Adjustable Pillow Top
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1299
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Art & Science Gold
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Avatar Sensus
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Bedgear M2
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Breeze Medium Cool Gel Euro Top Pocket
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Breeze Firm Queen Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$479
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Brosa Firm Favourite
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$949
Unlock this by becoming a member
Clark Rubber Comfort Platinum Latex
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$689
Unlock this by becoming a member
Clark Rubber Comfort Deluxe (100mm)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$365
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Comfort Sleep Verve Accent
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1299
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Deep Dream Charcoal Infused Pocket Spring Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$549
Unlock this by becoming a member
Dusk & Dawn Essential MK2
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1749
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Dusk & Dawn Essential
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1649
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ecosa Essence
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$690
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ecosa Pure (2023 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in medium-soft configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1700
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ecosa Mattress (2022 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1150
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ecosa Mattress (2020 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ecosa Mattress (2018 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ergoflex 5G Memory Foam Mattress
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1600
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Eva Premium Adapt (2022 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1640
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Eva Mattress (2019 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1050
Unlock this by becoming a member
Eva Comfort Classic (2023 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1200
Unlock this by becoming a member
Fantastic Escape
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Fantastic Serenity
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Home by Tempur Medium
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1200
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Vestmarka
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$249
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Vesteroy
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$349
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Ånneland
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Valevåg
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Åkrehamn
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Vatneström
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Ikea Abygda
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Morgedal
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hyllestad firm
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hokkåsen
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hidrasund
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hesseng
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hafslo
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$249
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Hövåg
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$449
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Fillan
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Ikea Asvang
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$349
Unlock this by becoming a member
Kmart Euro Top Pocket Spring
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$279
Unlock this by becoming a member
Koala Mattress (2024 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1290
Unlock this by becoming a member
Koala Plus
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1450
Unlock this by becoming a member
Koala SE
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$950
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Koala Soul Mate
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2890
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Koala Mattress (2021 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1200
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Koala Mattress (2018 model)
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1050
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Koala Calm As Mattress
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1700
Unlock this by becoming a member
Macoda Mattress
Hybrid mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1300
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Noa Mattress (2021 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1199
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Noa Luxe
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1549
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Noa Lite
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1395
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Noa Mattress (2020 model)
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
OneBed Original 10"
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1250
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
OneBed Mattress
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Not specified
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1000
Unlock this by becoming a member
Origin Hybrid Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$809
Unlock this by becoming a member
Original Mattress Factory Revivify
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$848
Unlock this by becoming a member
Original Mattress Factory Refresh
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2598
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Original Mattress Factory Original P2
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$598
Unlock this by becoming a member
Peacelily Queen Mattress
Latex mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sealy Posturepedic Crown Jewels Reims Flex
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$8399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sealy Posturepedic Exquisite Excellence
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$5599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sealy Advantage Gel Active
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1299
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sealy Atlanta
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Back Support Harmony
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturesense Hendrix
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Performance Vancouver
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Exquisite St Moritz
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Elevate Tradition
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Elevate Sienna
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Super-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Elevate Revive
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Elevate Oslo
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Elevate Marbella
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1250
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Aspire Swan
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Aspire Revive
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Aspire Belmonte
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2199
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posture Sense Miami Deluxe
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Metro series Loft
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Cambridge Posturepedic Climate Cool
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Cambri Firm
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Active +
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sealy Posturepedic Exquisite Iridium
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$5599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Silent Partner Cosmopolitan
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1699
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Silent Partner Bellagio
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sleep Firm Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1269
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sleep Republic Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1599
Unlock this by becoming a member
SleepMaker Elements Jordan
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Ventura
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1199
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Support Comfort
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Silhouette Brooklyn
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$3299
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Miracoil Maple
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Miracoil Bright
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Miracoil Armadale
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2099
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Miracoil Advanced Comfort
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Kip Set mattress
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Not specified
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Impulse
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
SleepMaker Alaska
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sleeping Duck Mach II
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1649
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sleeping Duck Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1349
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sleeptailor Craftsman
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$3799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Sleeptight Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$189
Unlock this by becoming a member
Slumberland Soho
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$459
Unlock this by becoming a member
Slumberland Sutton Pillowtop
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Slumberland Stonehenge
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Slumberland Fulham
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Slumberland Ascot
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1149
Unlock this by becoming a member
Snooze Madison Times Square
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4799
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Snooze Madison Rockefeller
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Snooze Madison Grosvenor
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4199
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Sommuto Mattress
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Not specified
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$949
Unlock this by becoming a member
Suparest Affinity
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$599
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Tempur Original Prima Carina 19 CoolTouch
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$4899
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Tempur Lucerne Hybrid
Hybrid mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium-firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$6000
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Tontine Memory Foam Comfortech
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Not specified
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1669
Unlock this by becoming a member
Valmori Home Collection Spring Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1200
Unlock this by becoming a member
Valmori Home Collection Hybrid II
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1000
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Whiteheaven Bondi
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$2399
Unlock this by becoming a member
Discontinued
Wonderest Mattress
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Not specified
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$499
Unlock this by becoming a member
Zeek Original
Foam mattress
Claimed firmness
Firm
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$999
Unlock this by becoming a member
Zenna Latex Mattress
Latex mattress
Claimed firmness
Adjustable (tested in firm configuration)
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$1895
Unlock this by becoming a member
Zinus Support iCoil Pocket Spring Eurotop
Spring mattress
Claimed firmness
Medium
Unused mattress comfort score – male/female average
Member only
Comfort retention score after eight years – overall
Member only
Sagging score
Member only
$399
